3217 Goldsmith St

3217 Goldsmith St

Dbottom 20%

San Diego, CA 92106

$2,785,000
NEW — 0d
STR-eligible · San Diego Tier 3 · TOT 12.75%

One license per person in San Diego: whether you can hold it depends on you, not only the home.

This parcel holds a short-term rental license: Tier 3 (whole home), through Apr 2027. It doesn’t transfer: a buyer applies for their own.

30 licensed short-term rentals within ½ mile (15 whole home), from the cities' license and permit lists of Nov 17, 2026.

Pass at asking: -$15,534/mo full cashflow at 20% down, 7.36% rate.

Works at $752,299 (73% under asking); even all cash loses money at asking.

Rent $7,466/mo from 8 leases of 4–6 bed houses within 2 mi ($7,252–$8,005).

Beds

5

Baths

4.5

Sqft

2,548

Year Built

1926

Days on Market

0

Property Type

Single Family

HOA/mo

N/A

MLS ID

NDP2610323

This property is in San Diego (92106). View neighborhood stats →

Virtual Tour

About This Property

DOUBLE LOT --- ESTATE HOME WITH 3 BEDROOMS & 2 BATHS --- GUEST HOUSE WITH 2 BEDROOMS & 2 BATHS --- LARGE PRIVATE YARD WITH POOL AND SPA --- ROOM TO BUILD ADDITIONAL ADU. True indoor/outdoor living in this very, very private (remodeled) 1926 home in Point Loma/Pulmosa Park. Property includes a main house, detached guest house, a large private yard with a custom pool, spa. The main house has 3 bedrooms / 2 baths and a partially finished basement and finished laundry room. The detached guest is approximately 650+ sqft with 2 bedrooms /2 bath and kitchen (potential rent of $2,500). The flat double lot totals over 10,000 sqft (100ft frontage on goldsmith) and has room to possibly construct a two story 1,200 sqft, two bed/2 bath ADU and a two car detached tandem garage.................... EXTERIOR PROPERTY FEATURES COMPLETED BETWEEN 2016 & 2018: Design & Built a large private yard with a Pool and Spa (yard shielded from view by neighbors) - 180 sqft indoor/outdoor covered pool lanai attached to main house dining area - Fully enclosed property - Sunny garden center - Fully paid 11KW solar energy system - Commercial Grade TPO roof on main house & guest quarter - Synthetic stucco applied to main house and guest quarters - 200+ linear feet of concrete privacy walls - Side yard dog run - Storage garage - Private unfinished 50+ foot driveway & space for potential 1,200 Sqft 2 bed/2 bath ADU....................MAIN HOUSE INTERIOR FEATURES: Interior of main house and guest quarters remodeled in 2016 - Barrel vaulted ceilings - Hardwood maple flooring throughout - Kitchen with gas appliances - Dining area - Office space - En-suite master bedroom with custom walk-in closet - two additional large bedrooms each with a walk-in closet, one with attached bathroom - Dual pane windows throughout - HVAC - Custom light fixtures - Recessed lighting throughout - Basement with finished laundry room and additional unfinished space for a possible wine cellar, workshop or storage.................... DETACHED GUEST HOUSE INTERIOR FEATURES: The detached guest quarter building consists of two bedrooms with each with a private 3/4 bath. Bedrooms are located above a kitchen/sitting space and unfinished storage space (each about the size of a one car garage) which can be converted into one large living area. Hardwood floors - HVAC - recessed lighting - Light kitchen.............. (Broker does not guarantee information contained herein. Buyer to verify all information to their satisfaction.)

Mortgage Calculator

Est. Monthly Payment

$18,963

Principal & Interest$15,365
Property Tax$2,785
Insurance$812
%($557,000)
%
Loan Term

Location

Loading map...

Zoned Schools

  • Elementary

    Loma Portal Elementary · grades K-4 · San Diego Unified

  • Middle

    Correia Middle · grades 7-8 · San Diego Unified

  • High

    Point Loma High · grades 9-12 · San Diego Unified

The district's assigned schools for this parcel, from its attendance boundaries and rules. Boundaries change: confirm with the district before you buy.

Renovation math

Flagged Light Value-Add from the listing remarks — “unfinished”.

Asking now
$2.79M

$1,093/sqft

Worth finished
$2.12M

$830/sqft × 2,548 sqft

Already above finished value
−$669,697

$263/sqft over

Comparable finished homes nearby suggest this is worth about $2.12M — below the asking price. A renovation here has to be funded out of the purchase, not the spread.

Rent once renovated

Rent at par
$6,937/mo

$2.72/sqft × 2,548 sqft, median of 5 comps

Cashflow at that rent
−$15,942/mo

cap rate -0.10%, DSCR 0.37

Heads up: the rent estimate elsewhere on this page ($7,466/mo) is above what comparable finished homes here support. A home that needs work does not out-rent them, so treat $6,937/mo as the ceiling.

Buying at asking and achieving par rent, excluding the renovation spend itself. We don't publish a current-condition rent: no listing remark says how much work a home needs, and mid-renovation it earns nothing.

Based on 5 comparable homes of the same property type and size currently listed nearby — asking prices and modelled rents, not closed sales. A contractor's scope, not this page, decides what a renovation actually costs.

Investment Score

1D
Est. Monthly Rent
$7,466

8 leases of 4–6 bed houses within 2 mi · $7,252–$8,005

Monthly Cashflow

Rent − PITIA

-$11,496
Full Cashflow

Incl. vacancy, PM, maint, capex

-$15,534

What would make this work?

$15,534/mo short at 20% down; +$20,175/mo rent closes it.

Break-even price

73% under asking

$752,299
Break-even rent

$20,175/mo above the estimate

$27,641/mo
Cashflow at 35% down
−$12,653/mo
Down payment to break even

Negative even all-cash

Not reachable
Rate to break even

Negative even at a 0% loan

Not reachable

Mortgage (P+I)
$15,365
Cap Rate
0.09%
Cash-on-Cash
-33.47%
DSCR

Need ≥ 1.25 for DSCR loan

0.39

NOI (Annual)
$2,451
Price-to-Rent

Lower = better for investors

31.1

* Modelled at 20% down, 7.36% rate, 30yr · vacancy 8% · PM 10% · capex 5% · maintenance 1%/yr.

Estimates only. Not financial advice. Verify all figures independently with a licensed professional before making any investment decision.

Open Full Calculator
DCashflow−$15,534/mo